Ramadi, Iraq: A Mess
BY Herschel Smith18 years, 3 months ago
This post has been updated with Ramadi is Still a Troubled City.
**** SCROLL FOR UPDATES ****
Those of you who are consistent readers at my site (believe it or not, there are actually a few of you) know that when I think I see a spade, I call it a spade. Right or wrong, I call it like I see it.
I am a patriot. This post is not about the war in terms of its rightness or wrongness. It is about how we are conducting part of the war and the potentially terrible cost to U.S. lives that might result from our current strategy. It is time to weigh in on Ramadi. I think it is a mess, and I think that its a mess because of the tactical approach taken by the brass. This will not make me popular with the brass, but they don’t read my blog anyway, so I have lost nothing and I’ve kept my honesty.
Early on I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but pointed out that this tactic of surgically striking at the insurgents in Ramadi (while also leaving the civilians in the city) was prone to disaster and carried the risk of utter failure. Now, I feel that it is not only prone to disaster, but will also cost U.S. lives in the future.
I questioned in a earlier post on Ramadi “what kind of strategy digs a hole and puts U.S. troops in it waiting to be attacked,” or something like that (and in fact, the U.S. troops were taking bets as to when they would be attacked). Now, this from Ramadi:
Ramadi, Iraq – Peering over piles of sandbags in this ravaged city, US Marines sometimes see more gunmen on the streets than municipal employees going to work. The provincial governor regularly arrives at his office with armed gaurds in tow.
After three years of war in Ramadi, the US military has yet to move from combat to stabilization operations in most of this Sunni Arab city of 400,000 people, the capital of Anbar province.
Here full-fledged combat still rages. Efforts to build a local government have faltered.
In just four months, one Marine has fired 27 rockets. Another estimates he has fired 5,000 rounds from a .50-caliber machine gun. One marksman has 20 confirmed kills. His superiors believe he has probably killed another 40 but they are not sure.
The US military said Sunday that four US Marines assigned to the Regimental Combat Team 7 were killed in action in Anbar province, although it did not say where.
Residents of Ramadi are afraid of even walking near the offices of the Anbar provincial government, which is supposed to administer an area the size of Greece, and with about 1 million inhabitants.
“There’s been a concerted campaign against government officials that’s had some great success … the government center is nearly devoid of governance,
On August 2, 2006 at 3:20 am, You Must Be Kidding said:
Ramadi was a hell hole LAST year, too and 3ID took some terrible losses there… I hope the Marines and Army units there now are not just dug in waiting for the clock to tick down… and then 3ID or whoever rotates back there end of this year aren’t the worst for it… I say put everything we’ve got into it now and blast the crap outta the insurgents once and for all and let us go home and the Iraqis get on with it.
On August 2, 2006 at 5:04 am, caelestis said:
Ramadi was a hellhole back in 04 when I was with the 1st of the 1st ID. I was almost killed a few times, and it seemed like we never took the fight to the enemy.
On August 26, 2006 at 1:20 pm, Chris said:
in ramadi now and it seems the politics is what is holding us back on taking the city. I agree fully lets blast the hell outta these bastards. Sorry to say we are letting time kill us too…it sucks!!
On October 20, 2006 at 9:01 am, SGT Brad said:
I was with 3ID in Ramadi in 2005 and I know all about those terrible losses. Political issues aside, we never should have pulled the heavy 3ID out and replaced us with the light guys of the 101st. We should’ve been replaced with 4ID. All respect to the legs, but Ramadi has IEDs that split Brads and Tanks in half. We need a respectable heavy force (not just our one battalion) to go in there and crush the terrorists. Then the light boys can go clean up.