Mass in Counterinsurgency
BY Herschel Smith14 years, 10 months ago
From The New York Times:
Trucks gayly painted with hearts and doves jam up at crowded wayside bazaars. Billboards advertise cell phones and advise drivers to keep their donkeys off the road.
It’s not readily evident that this is probably the world’s most dangerous highway, a prime target for Taliban insurgents attempting to sever a vital, 1,000-kilometer (620-mile) artery with ambushes, executions and roadside bombs.
Widely seen as symbolic of Afghanistan’s progress and security, or lack of it, Highway 1 suffered a dramatic increase in bomb attacks in 2009, but also a marked improvement along a critical 90-kilometer (55-mile) stretch after U.S. forces arrived in strength.
”Last year the insurgents were very successful in interdicting convoys. They can’t stage that type of attack anymore,” says Lt. Col. Kimo Gallahue, who commands a U.S. battalion guarding the highway just south of Kabul. ”Since August we’ve been ripping through the enemy. Mass matters.”
The situation is starkly different as the highway veers farther south into the Taliban heartland. Overall, roadside bomb attacks have risen by more than 50 percent — from 308 in 2008 to 469 last year. But 394 were discovered before they detonated, up from 254 the previous year, according to a command spokesman, Lt. Col. Todd Vician.
Since the U.S. invasion of 2001, this vital land link between the country’s two largest cities has been hotly and violently contested. About 35 percent of Afghanistan’s population lives within 50 kilometers (30 miles) of the Kandahar-to-Kabul stretch, giving weight to the notion that ”as the highway goes, so goes the country.”
Battered by war and weather, the road got a $250 million makeover five years ago, halving the 12-hour, 483-kilometer (301-mile) drive between Kabul to Kandahar which have the two largest NATO bases. The U.S., Japan and Saudi Arabia then followed with an overhaul of the stretch from Kandahar to the western city of Herat.
Taliban leader Mullah Omar has good reason to target the road, says Col. David B. Haight, commander of U.S. forces in Wardak and Logar provinces which adjoin Kabul.
”If you were Omar, wouldn’t you want to attack the country’s most strategic highway, an icon of commerce economic progress? He sees traffic on the road and he doesn’t like it. He has tried to disrupt it but he can’t stop it,” Haight said.
”There’s never a day off. That road is very critical,” he says, noting that the U.S. military has intercepts from Omar to subordinates stressing the importance of the two provinces because of their locations along or near the highway.
In 2008, the Taliban did unleash intense strikes against the highway’s southern approach to Kabul where Gallahue’s troops now operate. In a series of spectacular attacks, three U.S. soldiers died in an ambush, one of them dragged off and mutilated beyond recognition, and in a separate action an entire 50-vehicle convoy ferrying supplies for U.S. forces was set ablaze and seven of its drivers beheaded.
That year, the U.S. military deployed a skeleton force of some 600 troops to stem a resurgent Taliban at the gates of Kabul in Wardak and Logar. This was boosted to more than 4,000 in early 2009, with seemingly significant effect.
This report is noteworthy for the roads and logistics issues which we have discussed, but more to the point, mass matters in contemporary counterinsurgencies. In the two most significant counterinsurgency campaigns in our lifetime, increased force projection was needed as I have advocated for three and a half years. So much for the notion that the large footprint model turns the population against the U.S. and creates more insurgents than we kill. There may be some turnaround point where this occurs, but we have yet to test that theory in real life situations.
On January 6, 2010 at 7:45 pm, Warbucks said:
”If you were Omar, wouldn’t you want to attack the country’s most strategic highway, an icon of commerce economic progress?”
Not this Omar.
If I were Omar, I would be paying attention to those unrelenting and continuing series of similar dreams I have every night and searching for their meaning and stop ignoring their intuitive inner voice.
If I were Omar, I would pray for guidance asking to see alternative routes we might as a religion take for peace instead of war.
If I were Omar, I would pray for personal revelation in a way I could understand.
If I were Omar I would retreat into the private part of my cave and ask God to awaken among my people what we need to do to enter and become a full partner in the modern age and recapture the richness, respect and love of others and regain the fullness of our most ancient days.
If I were Omar I would pray an anti-war leader of my own people rose up among us and helped those like me to lay down our arms and love all people.
If I were Omar…. I’d take a chance for peace…and my soul.