On the Proper Utilization of Resources in Afghanistan
BY Herschel Smith14 years, 7 months ago
This report comes from the AP.
GHUNDY GHAR, Afghanistan — As night falls on this small hilltop base in the heart of Taliban country in southern Afghanistan, U.S. Army soldiers break out their knives and flashlights and go hunting for some of the country’s deadliest inhabitants: snakes and scorpions.
Tracking down the “creepy crawlies” that lurk in the nooks and crannies of the countryside is a favorite pastime, providing education, some entertainment — arachnid fight night! — or even a quick meal.
The expeditions help break the monotony of 10-day rotations the soldiers do once or twice a month at this rugged outpost in Kandahar province. Other than patrolling for a few hours a day, there is little for troops to do except watch movies or lift weights at a makeshift gym.
“Deployments are always 99 percent extreme boredom and one percent sheer terror,” said Spc. Chris Stoughton, a 28-year-old machine gunner with the platoon currently based at Strong Point Ghundy Ghar in Zhari district.
Staff Sgt. Aaron Christensen, a self-described reptile nut who grew up exploring the woods and coastlines of Oregon, leads the charge at night. Unlike most soldiers on their first deployment, he was just as fired up about the wildlife in the Afghan countryside as he was about potentially battling Taliban insurgents.
“I knew we had our job to do, but I was thinking in the back of my mind that I hope to see some of the cool things I have only seen in pictures or at exotic reptile shows,” said Christensen, who has owned cobras, rattlesnakes, lizards and a small alligator as pets. He even has two of his pet snakes tattooed on his left biceps.
The 30-year-old native of Portland, Oregon, has not been disappointed with what he and his fellow soldiers have found around the 200-foot (60- meter) rock and mud hill where their base is located. It is teeming with a wealth of snakes, scorpions, spiders and other wildlife.
This is a good human interest story from the AP reporter (Sabastion Abbot) that raises an issue entirely different from the one he intended. Why are soldiers bored with little to do except look for reptiles, work out and watch movies? I don’t want to start another round of internecine rivalry, but the Marines in Helmand aren’t so bored.
“We set out the combat patrol anticipating contact,” said Capt. E.A. Meador from Laurel, Miss., the company commander. “They always try to hit us in that area.”
After moving only about one mile from their combat outpost, the Marines received a heavy volley of enemy gunfire from multiple directions. Without hesitation, the Marines and ANA returned fire to suppress the enemy positions, began to maneuver on the insurgents and call for fire support.
Within minutes, an AH-1W Super Cobra and a UH-1N Huey were on station overhead to help suppress and engage enemy targets. The Cobra fired several five-inch Zuni rockets into one of the compounds from which the patrol was receiving sustained fire.
During the engagement, the squad leaders were encouraging and directing their Marines to ensure they were doing everything they could to stay effective and in the fight. No matter how tired they became as time wore on, the voice of experience could be heard across the battlefield.
“Push forward. Keep your dispersion,” called out Sgt. Jonathon Delgado, a squad leader from Kissimmee, Fla., as his Marines pressed through the corn field to maneuver on one of the compounds hiding the enemy.
The Marines and ANA eventually maneuvered up to and cleared the insurgent positions initially used to launch the ambush. One moment they were fighting in open fields, and the next they were clearing rooms the insurgents had used as fighting positions – two very different and challenging combat techniques. One squad, expecting to encounter some resistance, went to clear the western compound where the patrol had initially taken heavy fire. As they entered the compound, the only thing that was they found were brass casings and links from the enemy’s machine guns.
“It was tense going through the compound,” Daughtry commented. “You never know exactly what is coming around the corner.”
Marines with Company E, 2nd Battalion, 8th Marine Regiment, suppress enemy positions to protect the landing zone for a casualty evacuation helicopter in the middle of a six-hour firefight with Taliban insurgents.
This was a six-hour firefight. Terry McCarthy has written about a four hour and fifteen minute patrol conducted by the 3/1 Marines. This isn’t about branches of the military. The Army in the Kunar and Nuristan Provinces is taking heat from the Taliban, and needs help on their many combat outposts. It’s an issue of expectations and utilization of resources. The question is why the Marines in Helmand and the Army is Kunar is suffering while the Army in other parts of the battlespace is bored?
Something is wrong with the management of the campaign.
On May 13, 2010 at 12:36 pm, BruceR said:
Special case, though. Ghundy Ghar (“Hill Mountain” in Pashto… that’s what we call it, locals just call it the “Ghundy”) is the dominant terrain feature for miles in every direction. It needs to be held to control Western Zhari District, but can be held with a very minimal force. The troops there are just hanging onto the pimple so that the insurgents can’t move in there and seed it with IEDs or use it as a lookout post. It would take a lot more effort to take it back each time we wanted that kind of high-ground overwatch than to keep it. But if we’re on top with a few guys and good optics, in that part of Afg they’re basically impregnable. Hence it’s always been a generally boring little outpost. To patrol the surrounding area more aggressively you’d need a much larger force than you need just to hold it, and those extra troops are needed elsewhere, too. So I wouldn’t fault the army battalion here so much for this one… take my word it actually makes some sense given the ground.