Beating And Robbery Stopped With Handgun
BY Herschel Smith
11 years ago
A northeast Minneapolis man interrupted an armed and bloody robbery at a corner market in his neighborhood, saying he sent the two suspects fleeing when he drew his handgun from his holster and had it “at the ready.”
Store owner Mohamed S. Ahmed, 41, had the “back of his skull split open pretty good” from being pistol-whipped by one of the suspects, said Matt Dosser, who came upon the unfolding crime scene and cared for Ahmed until police arrived.
Police said Wednesday that the armed citizen, who said he has a so-called “permit to carry,” acted with honor and probably saved Ahmed’s life. But, they added, holding such a permit does not mean having the same law-enforcing rights as a police officer.
[ … ]
Dosser said he was out for a walk and the two people, possibly in their late teens, “were pounding on the window of the store. … They seemed really agitated, super agitated.”
At first, “nothing made sense, then I saw the gun” that one of the two had, Dosser continued.
The gunman “turned around and looked at me,” Dosser said. “He stared at me. I had my weapon up. I didn’t point the gun at the person. I had it at the ready, out of the holster.
In 2003, Minnesota’s so-called “shall issue” permit law took effect, making it easier for residents to carry loaded weapons in public.
Police spokesman John Elder said that what Dosser did “was a noble thing. He acted honorably. Did this person possibly save [Ahmed’s] life? Absolutely.”
However, Elder continued, “The permit system is different, obviously, than having a police officer’s license. … When people get a permit to carry, they are instructed not to intercede into a crime that is occurring. It’s solely for personal protection.”
Leave it to the police to throw a wet blanket on the honorable act by setting themselves apart from citizens, just so that you know. It’s important to them that you know they are special.
He’s lying anyway (see Castle Rock v. Gonzales). Regarding the incident above, the man’s life was probably saved, and even if not, he got medical assistance sooner than would otherwise be the case.
In contrast, folks in Newark, New Jersey are facing an epidemic of crime.
Short Hills, New Jersey (My9NJ) – The two suspects wanted for the recent shooting of a young lawyer in front of his wife during a carjacking gone terribly wrong at Short Hills Mall, are still at large.
The couples’ stolen SUV was found the following day abandoned in Newark and New Jersey’s largest city ranks among the top in the nation for vehicle thefts.
There are about 400 carjackings a year in Essex County alone. While Los Angeles and New York rank high in carjackings, Newark takes the cake.
In fact, people in Newark are known for posting videos of stolen cars doing drag races, donuts and drifting in the streets. Often times, in the videos, you can see cop cars chasing the reckless divers on the city’s main streets.
Perhaps the motorists need guns for protection, and I’m willing to lay good money on the notion that the carjackings would stop if several of these criminals got shot during the act.
Er … oh yea. New Jersey isn’t a shall issue state. And Chris Christie – presumed candidate for the highest office in the land in several years and who made his fame pushing gun control – was unavailable for comment.
On December 19, 2013 at 9:23 am, Paul B said:
Electing Christie will be the second worst thing the electorate has done. The only person on the political scene who has the right stuff is Palin. Lets follow the first black president with the first woman president.
On December 20, 2013 at 9:50 am, jean said:
Newark is a wasteland with significant no go areas, their mayor is a media darling. I am glad that I no longer have to travel to that area. As a matter of fact, I have made a choice not travel or do business in areas where I am not allowed to defend myself: Voting with my feet and my wallet.
On December 20, 2013 at 2:06 pm, BHirsh said:
“But, they added, holding such a permit does not mean having the same law-enforcing rights as a police officer.”
Fail. This observation was extraneous and unnecessary, since Mr. Dosser didn’t pursue the suspects or attempt to take them into custody, but attended to Mr. Ahmed’s well-being instead.
Citizens have the common law right to do whatever it takes to stop a forcible felony, up to and including lethal force. This is true no matter in which venue in the U.S. the felony occurs.
On December 21, 2013 at 1:46 pm, Ned said:
I remember an incident in Arizona where a guy who worked nights was returning from work in the wee hours of the morning. He stopped at a stoplight, and a carjacker screwed a gun into his ear.
When the driver opened the door, he shot the carjacker in the femur and drove off, leaving the criminal POS bleeding in the street. Don’t remember if the guy defending his life ever came forward. Probably just wanted to get home, have a bite of food and go to bed.
I believe this matter was reported by other witnesses.