Somebody’s Got A Screw Loose, And It Ain’t Smith & Wesson
BY Herschel Smith8 years, 10 months ago
A lawsuit filed against Smith & Wesson in federal court last Thursday alleges that the plaintiff lost a finger due to a defective part on an unaltered .380 Bodyguard firearm.
Randy and Vicki McNeal, of Trimble, Tennessee, are seeking $75,000 in compensation – as well as legal fees – from the Massachusetts-based firearms manufacturer as a result of injuries received when Randy McNeal attempted to operate the firearm, which the plaintiffs alleged was “damaged, defective and unreasonably dangerous” when first manufactured, according to the complaint.
According to the complaint, McNeal purchased the firearm for his wife from a dealer in Jonesborough, Tennessee, in August of 2011, and no alterations were made to the firearm since its purchase.
The injury occurred approximately two years later, in December 2013, when he was attempting to make the gun safe to show a friend at On Target Guns and Indoor Range in Murfreesboro, Tennessee.
According to the complaint, McNeal attempted to lock the slide back to ensure the chamber was empty, but due to an obstruction the slide wouldn’t come back all the way and lock into place. In an attempt to correct the problem, McNeal “briskly drew back the slide several times,” while following instructions from the gun’s safety manual.
However, the gun slipped from his grip, and when McNeal caught it, the firearm accidentally discharged, hitting his left small finger, ultimately leading to a need to amputate, the complaint says.
The plaintiffs, who reportedly had a firearms expert inspect the weapon, allege that the reason the gun could not be made safe – and ultimately the cause of the injury – was because of a loose screw on the built-in laser sight, which they say is “a defect/quality control issue.”
I’ve been hard on Remington for failure to come clean on their Walker fire control system. But this is a loose screw. I and every one of my readers has been at the range, or cleaning your weapons, or dry firing them, and found parts that needed to be tightened, refurbished, reformed, replaced, cleaned, or jettisoned for some other reason.
If you don’t want a screw to back out, check it periodically, or put Loctite on it [Be warned, this comes at a cost too. AR aficionados don’t like the fact that Rock River Arms secures the Castle Nut on their rifles with red Loctite – it makes it virtually impossible to get off without a torch if you want to replace the buffer tube].
And above all else, when you drop a gun, do not try to catch it. There are enough safety features on modern guns that catching it won’t prevent anything from happening except a little scratching when it hits, and may expose you to pulling the trigger of your weapon. For instance, Ruger’s revolvers have their transfer bar, other makers have their features.
Again, do not try to catch a falling gun. Ever. My apologies for the awful music. And for heaven’s sake, drop the gun, and drop the lawsuit.
On January 27, 2016 at 10:18 am, TexTopCat said:
I know of no one that has not been told to not try to catch a falling gun. Also, a check for loose screws, pins, and such is part of normal maintenance. If the slide does not come back or the gun jams in some other non-obvious matter, most ranges require you to notify range safety officer before any attempt to correct the problem.
On January 27, 2016 at 11:02 am, Ned Weatherby said:
Good heavens. The idiot drops, then tries to catch, a falling loaded pistol. He’s lucky enough that he only shot his pinky off. Then the idiot TELLS the whole world about it. There’s a defect here somewhere, alright, but it’s not a firearm problem.
I believe that S&W should offer to refund his money, and not sell him another S&W product until he can show he’s not a danger to himself and others.
And I don’t believe in mandatory training.
On January 27, 2016 at 7:49 pm, Michael Schlechter said:
That song was about 2:30 too long; even then it would have been barely tolerable. I was not formally taught not to catch a dropped gun, but it seemed obvious to me.
On January 28, 2016 at 10:23 pm, Herschel Smith said:
And yet you watched the entire thing, didn’t you? Sort of like a car crash, you cannot not look.
On January 29, 2016 at 7:03 pm, Michael Schlechter said:
Nope. I tried, but my wife was in the same room and she asked me “What is that horrible song?” I was embarrassed enough to just nix it.
On January 27, 2016 at 10:41 pm, Bill said:
I have been a gunsmith for over thirty years. I was not there when this incident happened, but I can tell you that I have seen this malfunction with one type of laser that S&W uses on the Bodyguard pistol. If I recall correctly it is the Laserlyte version. The battery compartment is built into the frame of the pistol and uses a diagonally threaded screw. I have seen them inserted and cross-threaded by owners trying to change the laser battery, as well as seeing them back out on their own.
Understand, I’m not accusing or pointing a finger at any individual or at S&W. I’m just telling it as I have personally dealt with it.
Cheers
On January 28, 2016 at 10:24 pm, Herschel Smith said:
Ah, you made the mistake of telling me you’re a professional gunsmith. Now I’ll know who to go to for questions.
On January 28, 2016 at 8:34 pm, UNCLEELMO said:
‘Somebody’s got a screw loose, and it ain’t Smith & Wesson’
Good one, Herschel.