Remembering Antonin Scalia
BY Herschel Smith8 years, 10 months ago
When I found out about Scalia’s death on Saturday, I yelled “No, No, No, No,” fifteen or twenty times at the top of my lungs. Much badness will follow.
While Mitch McConnell has said that the vacancy will be filled by the next president, he is a traitor like Paul Ryan. The Senate and House have given Obama everything he’s asked for seven years. They won’t stop now. Ted Cruz has promised to filibuster any nominee, and good on him for planning this ahead of time. I predict that the other senators will hang him out to dry like the worthless, quisling traitor, spineless crap weasels they are and like they did on his filibuster of Obamacare funding.
As to Scalia, I found that his Heller decision was his weakest, and leaves us with much work to be done by the Supreme Court in the future. Perhaps it was the best he could get past the other justices, but he is now dead and the balance of the court may change for the worse. This is a lesson for future justices. Don’t do things incrementally. We may not have you around long enough to finish the job.
His best work was in his dissents, and if you haven’t read the book “Scalia Dissents,” you owe it to yourself to get it and read it. Not only is it educational for the cases that have been before the court (you need some understanding of them in order to understand his dissent), but it is a window into one of the great minds of the twentieth century. His jurisprudence is a demarcation of the legal landscape for generations to come.
On a personal note, I do not know and have never met Scalia. But my brother, who graduated from Emory Law School, has met him and had a chance to discuss his writings. One question my brother posed went something like this. “I admire your decisions and dissents, but what I really wanted to ask you pertains to your writing style and abilities. Your writings can be understood by scholar and layman alike, and in my opinion it is part of what has made you so successful. How did you learn to communicate the way you do?”
Scalia responded something like this. “Thank you, I spent time reading and studying everything C.S. Lewis wrote. Read and study his writings and you’ll find someone who can communicate to both scholar and layman.” As for my reaction to what my brother relayed to me, I’m not surprised. I know someone who visited England recently and took the C.S. Lewis tour, in which they saw his home, where he taught, personal effects and other such things.
The tour was given by one person, and my friends were the only ones on the tour. “England,” said the tour guide, “has forgotten about Lewis. The only people I guide now are Americans.” How tragic. Lewis was a national treasure. So too, Scalia was a national treasure. I fear we will not really know what we had and be able to miss it with necessary earnestness for a very long time. But at least with me, I will not forget C.S. Lewis, and I won’t forget Scalia. National treasures are like that.
On February 15, 2016 at 2:41 pm, z--man said:
Here we have a US Supreme Court Judge, Antonin Scalia, found dead in his room, at a resort owned by a Democrat Party donor with ties to the current Democrat President, with no protection from the US Marshal’s service. Scalia had a pillow over his face. His death was ruled “of natural causes”, over the phone. The body wasn’t examined. No autopsy will take place. It’s treated as “nothing to see here, move along!”…… On the other hand, We have thug Michael Brown, robs a store, attacks a cop, gets shot, and no less than five autopsies were performed. It’s treated as a national incident. Does that make sense? Not to mention that two weeks ago, Hillary said that Obama would make a great USSC Justice…. Coincidence?
On February 16, 2016 at 2:02 pm, Dave said:
I used to sell health insurance here in Texas. State law (at the time, if I recall, and may still be in place) was that unless you died in a hospital, an autopsy had to be performed. This looks and sounds like the Kennedy assassination in Dallas, where the local coroner was denied the ability to determine cause of death, and was denied an autopsy, and his body was “stolen” from Dallas County. Scalia’s body was stolen from Presidio County, and the Sheriff there grinned when it happened. Democratic, hispanic sheriff, Democratic, hispanic local justice of the peace and her “si se puede”. When it comes to stealing murdered bodies here in Texas, yes you can!
On February 15, 2016 at 4:13 pm, Heyoka said:
I agree isr, we are all in a world of shit….
On February 16, 2016 at 12:00 pm, Ned Weatherby said:
First thoughts – what a terrible loss, and nothing good can come of this. The no autopsy matter will forever raise questions that should have been put to rest.
Even if congress manages to block Obama’s supreme court recommendations (I suspect Obama will find a way to appoint whomever he chooses anyhow, and the anemic Republicans will do nothing but complain) we are truly in a world of hurt.
Someone has the pictures of Justice Roberts, so the court as it now stands is out of balance towards the Prozi wing.
On February 16, 2016 at 6:01 pm, z--man said:
So…. if Obama gets a far-left wacko on the USSC…. why not just ignore them altogether? Democrats have been ignoring immigration law for decades now.