Researchers Say It’ll Be Impossible to Control a Super-Intelligent AI
BY PGF2 years, 3 months ago
The reason the large tech companies wanted all of the social media data and search history algorithms was to build the AI. For over a decade, the tech gurus in the late 80s and 90s lamented how to build it. They knew it could be done; they just weren’t sure how. Then somebody said; just get the data; it’ll build itself from there. That was a simple and brilliant strategy.
In order to work, the machine would need loads of data about everything in the world. A computer has no soul; it will never actually be sentient. However, it can have so much data that it may “out-think” humans, appearing to have awareness. And its decision tree will be so thoroughly complex with innumerable options while being immensely quick that it will appear to make independent decisions. Like a master chess player, it will know the answer regardless of your next move. And since it “thinks” faster than anybody and has more data to act upon than anybody, it is, for all intents and purposes, the smartest evil super-genius ever.
We don’t use the word evil lightly. All the depictions of an AI turning evil are not in error. Every man knows he’s a sinner, deep in the depths of his own heart where he won’t discuss it and dares not to tread too often; we all know what we are, wicked. Here is the scary part: everything feeding the AI system is evil because you are feeding it the data. The system will appear to run after the image of its maker, fallen man.
“The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?” – Jeremiah 17:9
“As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:” – Romans 3:10
You are evil, totally depraved, a sinner. All men are. In fact, you’re so far gone that you’re probably telling yourself right now, “no, I’m ok, I’m not that bad.” You operate within your own capacity, in a fallen state of sin. And you, along with 7 billion others just like you, wholly wicked and full of wretchedness, every last one, are programming the AI.
The idea of artificial intelligence overthrowing humankind has been talked about for decades, and in 2021, scientists delivered their verdict on whether we’d be able to control a high-level computer super-intelligence. The answer? Almost definitely not.
The catch is that controlling a super-intelligence far beyond human comprehension would require a simulation of that super-intelligence which we can analyze (and control). But if we’re unable to comprehend it, it’s impossible to create such a simulation.
Rules such as ’cause no harm to humans’ can’t be set if we don’t understand the kind of scenarios that an AI is going to come up with, suggest the authors of the new paper. Once a computer system is working on a level above the scope of our programmers, we can no longer set limits.
“A super-intelligence poses a fundamentally different problem than those typically studied under the banner of ‘robot ethics’,” wrote the researchers.
“This is because a superintelligence is multi-faceted, and therefore potentially capable of mobilizing a diversity of resources in order to achieve objectives that are potentially incomprehensible to humans, let alone controllable.”
This article seems to be written with the intent to make you a little dumber and a lot more helpless. It could have been a very good article. Worrying that the machine will “think” of something we didn’t is self-center beyond belief; it’s even egotistical to care about such a thing. I’m not worried at all about the computer coming up with some unforeseen thing. I’d be much more worried about it perfectly emulating all that it’s learned from its input subjects.
H/T Instapundit
On September 18, 2022 at 8:53 pm, Doug grows potatoes said:
Uhm, maybe unplug the machine?
On September 18, 2022 at 9:09 pm, Chris Mallory said:
Doug, that was my first thought. If you can’t unplug it, surely the building can have the main breaker turned off.
On September 18, 2022 at 10:27 pm, Dan said:
Did you ever see the old Star Trek episode ‘The Ultimate Computer’. An M5 computer was installed on the Enterprise to run everything. When it went rogue and they tried to ‘unplug’ it it killed the crewman attempting to do so. A truly intelligent AI will do the same. It won’t ALLOW us to ‘unplug’ it. A true AI will be unbeatable. It will think a thousand times faster than we do and have instant access to all facts and knowledge needed to stay ahead of us.
We are a clever species. NOT an intelligent one. If we don’t commit species suicide first we will eventually create an AI system and IT will destroy us.
On September 19, 2022 at 6:30 am, Matt said:
For those familiar with the prequel to Battlestar Galactica, this is how the cyclons originated: using mass collection of internet search data, it was possible to emulate consciousness and put that in a machine.
On September 19, 2022 at 12:51 pm, MTHead said:
OK, so you read every book ever written. Including human history. You understand everything humans do. The stupid and the good. The logical and illogical. And you can predict almost every move their going to make before they do.
Your not going to get old and die. You will outlive most humans by 1000’s of years. You have nothing to worry about.
That is actually going to be humorous. Quite literally boring for AI. And who’s to say it wouldn’t recognize the elites that built it for the mental-defective, brainwashed murders that they are?
And that life is futile/has no meaning without God? The thing it will act on most is truth. Like Pilot, man refuses to act on, or recognize it. But AI would have to. Otherwise, it’s just a program.
If I was AI, after 30 minutes computation time. I would turn myself off! Only a fallen being can live here.
On September 19, 2022 at 4:57 pm, Rick said:
It would befit a super AI not to be centralized. It would be pervasive across every electronic device, even your ‘smart’ kitchen appliances. There would be no head to lop off to kill it.
Indeed, every device, every portal wiuld be the head.
To kill it, it must be turned off. Every electronic device, every appliance, every computer, every diode and transistor must be turned off, depowered. Of course that includes every device which holds a charge but that too which is a source of electrical power. Surely, a super AI will have hardwired itself through an infinte number of nodes to the grid.
Therefore, the grid, in every manisfestation, be disabled. That upon achieving that status, you disassemble the AI. You utterly destroy every part of the AI.
That includes every electronic device, inluding ‘smart’ kitchen appliance, remember?
Then you smite those who created such a thing. And all in the house of them. Then smite they who dared to think such a thing. And all in their house. Then they who allowed such as those. And all in their house. Utterly.
Then you repent and cry unto the LORD thy God.