I didn’t respond to this comment at the time because I wanted it to “soak” a while first. Here is Steve Kellmeyer’s comment on a previous post.
Shooting individual hogs is a VERY bad idea. The only way to eradicate feral hogs is to capture an entire SOUNDER, the whole thing, at one time. If you just kill individual hogs, they break into multiple sounders which all go their separate ways. You turn them into quicksilver and they spatter everywhere.
There are ways to catch whole sounders at once. Do that. You get more meat for the poor, you actually eradicate the population.
Steve isn’t a thinking man. No one is going to “eradicate” the feral hog population. Hear me now and hear me good. Feral hogs are around for good. They will not be eradicated. Period. Full stop. But this comment goes further by asserting that “If you just kill individual hogs, they break into multiple sounders which all go their separate ways.”
Steve has never hunted hogs before. That isn’t how any of this works. Hogs sometimes travel in sounders, sometimes not. Sometimes if there is a sounder, it might consist of a few hogs, mostly sows, but even sows run alone sometimes. I’ve seen it. Boars mostly run alone. They may come back to a sounder from time to time for copious mating, but they don’t necessarily stick around other hogs all the time. When you see hogs, you may see one, or you may see two, or you may see twenty at a time. The boars that are alone aren’t in some sort of panic to get around a sounder because he loves his pigs. Wildlife biologists are anthropomorphizing hog behavior.
They travel in the day, they travel in the night time hours. They adapt and adjust rapidly, and no one tactic will be successful all the time and in all circumstances. They feed in the day, they are nocturnal feeders. They defy strict categorization, regardless of what “Steve” says. Ask me how I know. I know partly because I’m not a pointy head wildlife biologist who thinks he can write a journal article or be interviewed for the newspaper, or contract a hired hand, and make things okay.
That seems to be the way of things at the moment while time is ebbing away to cap their population. Witness this article concerning Canada’s exploding feral hog population.
What Manitoba does have are provincial rules that allow wild pig hunting any time of year with no bag limit, or restriction on number of animals they take. In B.C., “hunting is the only control measure,” the Invasive Species Council wrote in 2019. In Saskatchewan, although “wild boar may be shot by Saskatchewan residents without a licence to protect their property, hunting is not a recommended control measure,” Sharks explained in an email.
Alberta’s strategy incentivizes hunting directly, offering to pay hunters $75 per set of ears. The CBC reported last fall that zero kills had been made in the bounty program, but Brook is not a fan of the idea.
“I have been vocally saying that a bounty is a great option if you want more wild pigs. That is a fantastic strategy — if you want to double your pigs,” Brook said sarcastically.
He explains that research shows hunting actually accelerates the spread of wild pigs, as they flee to new areas to evade hunters.
Instead, the wildlife biologist recommends hiring a professional trapper. Next up, this stupid article.
An open hunt intended to eradicate Alberta’s wild boar population may instead make the feral swine more elusive to bounty hunters, a researcher warns.
The province has placed a price on the heads of wild pigs — re-establishing a bounty program designed to root out stubborn populations of the invasive species.
The hunt must be carefully managed, said Ryan Brook, an associate professor in the agriculture department of the University of Saskatchewan and director of the Canada Wild Pig Research Project.
Sporadic hunting will make the animals harder to track, Brook said. Wild boar quickly learn to disperse and evade threats — and will pass these tricks onto their young.
They already know those lessons, Ryan, and if they don’t, they’ll learn them in a single day when your local trapper puts out corn feeders and drops cages on them. I could go on and on with these articles, but you get the picture. Some of them want to hire professional “sharpshooters,” as if he can do something that a hunter can’t or his shot won’t scatter a sounder while a hunter’s shot will (by the way, neither will happen). They want to use tactics that will be equally found out and learned by the hogs. Additionally, those methods are affecting the known, visible hog population, not the ones we know are there but not cataloged by the pointy head wildlife biologists.
I repeat, feral hogs won’t be eradicated. It’s not going to happen. It’s far too late for that. These hog cages dropping on corn feeders require expensive material and construction, cameras, people watching and patterning them, and they’re good for about as long as one or two catches, and then it’s over. The hogs won’t come back after investing weeks of patterning the hogs and ensuring that they are healthy with good food. And the trappers charge a lot of money. Besides, this video shows what happens fairly well – the catch of this massive operation is about 50 hogs with two cages.
There are more than 1.5 million feral hogs in Texas alone. That estimate is probably very low. At 1.5 million hogs, 50 per massive nighttime operation, and assuming 10 such catches per night over the state (consider the cost of an operation like that), it would take 3000 days or 8.22 years to make your way through the population assuming no reproduction at all.
Do you see the scope of the problem?
So follow the pointy head wildlife biologist’s advice and trap if that’s what you want to do. Also, hunt them, individually and collectively, alone and in sounders. Don’t poison them as I’ve seen some idiots suggest because that poison will make its way into the ecosystem. That may be the dumbest solution I’ve seen floated.
But to assert that killing a hog will make the problem worse is the most asinine advice I’ve witnessed. Feral hogs don’t fit neatly into your Aristotelian categories. Your error is in trying to categorize them at all. Don’t categorize them – kill them.
They don’t do what you would predict, and they won’t do what you want. If you want to cap the feral hog population, do everything possible to kill as many as you can by any means you can wherever and whenever you can. Hunters are not the problem and the solution isn’t another tax and public works project.
Got it?